The Story Hidden Within A Story {Book Club}

Walk Two Moons

Amazon describes Newberry award winning Walk Two Moons by Sharon Creech this way:

Thirteen-year-old Salamanca Tree Hiddle, proud of her country roots and the “Indian-ness in her blood,” travels from Ohio to Idaho with her eccentric grandparents. Along the way, she tells them of the story of Phoebe Winterbottom, who received mysterious messages, who met a “potential lunatic,” and whose mother disappeared.

As Sal entertains her grandparents with Phoebe’s outrageous story, her own story begins to unfold—the story of a thirteen-year-old girl whose only wish is to be reunited with her missing mother.

Though we have only read the first fifteen chapters this week, this summary has set up the plot well. The writing is beautiful and worthy of winning an award. As Sal is telling the story, I get a strong sense of her voice and the way she is trying to make sense of her world.

Thus far we know that her mom is gone (I’m guessing she’s dead, are you? And I’m guessing she left home because of the death of Sal’s unborn brother. What I’m not sure is, why that town in Idaho or why she died. I could also be WRONG.). Salamanca Tree Hiddle—aka Sal—has moved up north to be near what seems to be a new girl friend (Margaret Cadaver) and she is trying to deal with grief and building a new life.

Themes I’ve noticed in the first 15 chapters:

  • Grief—clearly as Sal is grieving leaving her home and town she loved, as well as the absence of her mom
  • Strong family—Sal references both sets of grandparents still being married and her dad is invested in Sal
  • Importance of roots—as Sal finds herself uprooted and making new friends
  • The power of story—as the story weaves back and forth between Phoebe and Sal

Questions I have thus far:

  • What has happened to Sal’s mom?
  • Why didn’t her dad come on the road trip?
  • Who is leaving notes at—is it Mary Lou or Phoebe’s—house?
  • What trouble are the journals going to cause?!

Lines I really liked:

  • “Just over a year ago, my father plucked me up like a weed and took me and all of our belongings (no, that is not true—he did not bring the chestnut tree, the willow, the maple, the hayloft, or the swimming hole which belonged to me.)” I love how Sal touches on the deeper aspect of her belongings.

 

  • “The reason that Phoebe’s story reminds me of that plaster wall and the hidden fireplace is that beneath Phoebe’s story was another one. Mine.” So true! Often I understand my own story/life and I am telling someone else’s.

 

  • “I was only thirteen, and although I did have a way with maps, it was not really because of that skill I was going [on the road trip], nor was it to see the ‘whole ding-dong country’ that Gram and Gramps were going. The real reasons were buried beneath piles and piles of unsaid things.” Ah yes, often reasons for doing something are complex and “buried beneath piles of unsaid things.

 

  • “I certainly do know heaps of stories, but I learned most of them from Gramps. Gram suggested I tell one about my mother. That I could not do. I had just reached the point where I could stop thinking about her every minute of every day.” The line “that I could not do.” So honest. So true in grief.

 

  • “It is surprising all the things you remember just by eating a blackberry pie”. It is amazing how powerfully some memories return through our senses. I enjoyed getting a sense of Sal’s family when it was the three of them!

 

  • “I had not said anything about what had happened the day before—about being scared down to my very bones when I thought they had left me. I don’t know what came over me. Ever since my mother left us that April day, I suspected that everyone was going to leave, one by one.” Doesn’t your heart just melt for kids who have experienced loss? Even “normal” loss of a parent getting ill, dying, or needing to move. Nothing violent or war torn, still, the tears and rips for the child are deep and real.

 

  • “Later that afternoon when Phoebe and I went downstairs, Mrs. Winterbottom was talking with Prudence [Phoebe’s mother and sister]. ‘Do you think I lead a tiny life?’ she asked. . . . All the way home I wondered about Mrs. Winterbottom and what she meant about having a tiny life.” I think we can all relate. I know at times I have wondered if I was leading a tiny life.

The road trip and stories will continue! Was your family the kind that stopped and looked at signs about monuments and historical places? Or did you keep stops to a minimum? (My dad was famous for wanting us in and out of a rest stop in the fastest time possible :)).

What have you noticed about Sal? What do you think about Phoebe, her family, and the other characters? Who are you most drawn to? Enough! See you in the comments!

Amy

P.S. Next week we will read chapters 16-29, and finish the book the week after that. On my blog I shared the 17 best books I read in 2017 (Several were book club reads!)

 

Photo by João Silas on Unsplash

10 Comments

  1. Dorette Skinner (@reporterofhope) January 9, 2018

    This really seems like a good read, but for some reason the Amazon Kindle version (link) says: “this title is not currently available for purchase”.. there is only a 85 page guide available, but I think that’s not the same one.. Any ideas other ideas how to get a copy?

    1. sarah January 9, 2018

      I just went directly to Amazon.com right now and purchased a Kindle edition of the book. Maybe the problem is fixed? Or, maybe you just need to skip the link and go direct to the site? Hope it works out for you!

    2. Phyllis January 10, 2018

      I checked out a Kindle version through Overdrive from my MIL’s library. I think it’s on Hoopla, too.

      1. Dorette Skinner (@reporterofhope) January 10, 2018

        Thank you everyone, seems like I’ll have to read the text version.. And since I’m a South African (reason why I can’t download the book as well) I doubt if it will be on our overdrive app (South Africa is slow to catch on and my library card is linked to a small town in the Free State so I can only check out books they have which I assume is much more limited than American libraries). Hope that we’ll get there eventually 😉

  2. Cassidy January 9, 2018

    I love Sal. Her attitude, honesty and realism are easy to soak in and you feel like you truly know her. I have so many questions.
    Is Gram going to be okay?
    Whats with the journals?
    Is Mrs. Cadavar really as sketchy as Pheobe believes?
    The grandparents make me miss my own grandparents. They are so in love, and comfortable with each other. I love their banter about Gloria and their ‘marriage bed’ so far a marriage to aspire to for sure. I can’t wait to learn more about these characters.

  3. Spring January 10, 2018

    I grew up with a dad who didn’t make a lot of money, but had long vacation. He loved to visit placed all over the US. We would travel long hours and set up our tent each night. We saw a lot, but didn’t stop often. The destination ws the goal. We lived off of pb&j sandwiches. I love how Sals grandparents stop randomly.

  4. Maria January 10, 2018

    I’m loving the book! (Although I was two days late with getting through chapter 15 – I’m famously late with reading assignments). So much heart in this dear child who has seen so much grief. I have so many questions, too:
    – strange little detail, but it gnaws at me: how is the teacher connected to Margaret?
    -Yes, along with the rest of you – are the journals a passing moment or will they uncover more?
    -What has happened to mom? At first, I was convinced they were headed to her grave. Now, at times, I wonder if they’ll find her in a psychological ward of sorts. Such a sad piece.
    I’m anxious to keep reading! I, too, am loving how Phoebe’s story uncovers Sal’s. What a true picture of life – what a true picture of how community helps us see ourselves for who we really are.
    Thanks to whoever chose this one!

  5. Maria January 10, 2018

    Ok – pardon the ENORMOUS picture of yours truly. I was trying to insert a profile pic, and well, now I can’t figure out how to edit my comment and remove it!

  6. sarah January 13, 2018

    I think maybe what impresses me most about Sal is her strong sense of identity. She knows exactly where she comes from, what she loves. I think maybe having moved away from our extended family when I was 12, and then not seeing then often after that, disrupted that strong sense of “this is who we are” and how that relates to who I am. And, I think it took me much longer than 13 to be able to confidently say, I Like this and I Don’t Like that.
    It’s good, though. There’s such consistency in the writing about who Sal is that it feels seamless to slip into her thinking and voice.

What do you think?

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.